Guide
Is a Smart Thermostat Right for Your Home? What to Check First
13 min read
We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on our site. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
A smart thermostat can do things an ordinary one can't. You can change the temperature from your phone, let someone else help from elsewhere, and get a notification if something seems wrong at home. For some households, that makes keeping the house comfortable noticeably easier.
But smarter isn't automatically easier. More features also mean more to set up: an app, an account, a Wi-Fi connection, and automatic behaviour you may or may not want. And not every thermostat works with every heating and cooling system, so compatibility has to be checked before you buy, not after.
This guide helps you decide whether a smart thermostat fits the way your household actually uses its thermostat, and what to confirm before replacing the one on your wall. It doesn't rank products or recommend models.
Quick answer
A smart thermostat may be worth considering if…
- you'd like to change the temperature from your phone, or want someone else to be able to help remotely
- you'd rather manage schedules in an app than at the wall
- notifications about your home's temperature or heating and cooling would be useful to you, knowing their limits
- your heating and cooling system passes the manufacturer's compatibility check
A simpler thermostat may be better if…
- you mostly set one temperature and leave it
- you'd rather not depend on Wi-Fi, an app or an online account
- your current thermostat is easy to use and does what you need
- your system is one that smart thermostats commonly don't support, such as electric baseboard heat
Either way, the table at the end of this guide lists what to check before you decide.
What a smart thermostat actually adds
Manual, programmable and smart, in plain terms
The words get used loosely, but there are three broad kinds of thermostat:
- Manual: you set the temperature, and it stays there until you change it.
- Programmable: it follows a schedule you set. The U.S. Department of Energy describes a programmable thermostat as one that automatically turns on the heating or air conditioning at times you schedule.
- Smart: ENERGY STAR, the federal efficiency program, describes a smart thermostat as a Wi-Fi-enabled device that automatically adjusts heating and cooling temperature settings. Most can be controlled from a phone app. Some also offer automatic features, such as learning your routine or noticing when no one is home.
You don't need a smart thermostat to have a schedule. Programmable thermostats have offered schedules for years. What a smart thermostat mainly adds is the internet connection: remote control, notifications, shared access, and automatic features that rely on an app and an account.
When a simpler thermostat may serve you better
A schedule only helps if it gets used. Research from a U.S. Department of Energy national laboratory, published in 2011, found that many households with programmable thermostats weren't using the programming, or found it confusing. That research predates today's smart models, but the lesson carries over: a feature you won't use doesn't make anything easier.
So if one steady temperature suits you, your current thermostat is easy to read and adjust, and no one needs to change it from somewhere else, a smart thermostat may add little.
Using it day to day: at the wall, in the app and by voice
At the thermostat itself
Whatever else it can do, you'll probably adjust the thermostat on the wall more often than anything else. Before buying, think about how it will feel to use every day:
- Can you read the display comfortably from where you usually stand, in daylight and at night?
- How do you change the temperature? Some thermostats use a dial, some use buttons, and some use a touchscreen or touch-sensitive controls. None of these is easier for everyone. What matters is whether the method suits the person who'll use it most.
- How many steps does an ordinary change take? Raising the temperature a couple of degrees should be quick, not a trip through menus.
- Which everyday changes can you make without your phone? Some models let you edit the schedule at the thermostat. With others, the schedule can only be set or changed in the app.
The manufacturer's instructions for basic tasks will show how many steps these take.
App control
Changing the temperature from a phone can be useful, whether that's warming the house before you get home or letting someone else help. Apps also tend to hold the detailed settings and the controls for sharing access. The trade-off is one more thing to manage: usually an account, a password and a working internet connection. Remote control is a convenience, not a requirement.
Voice control
Some smart thermostats can be adjusted by voice through a smart speaker or voice assistant, which can be handy if getting to the thermostat isn't always convenient. But voice control works only with compatible assistants, and these vary from one thermostat to another. It has to be set up and linked to your accounts, and it typically depends on internet services. Treat it as an extra, not as the main way to run the thermostat.
Schedules and automatic features
A schedule is the simplest kind of automation. You decide the temperatures and times, and the thermostat follows them. If you change the temperature by hand while a schedule is running, most programmable and smart thermostats treat that as a temporary change. They hold your setting for a while, then return to the schedule.
Many smart thermostats can go further:
- Learning or adaptive features adjust the schedule based on the changes you make over time.
- Home-and-away features change the temperature when the house seems empty. They may use motion or occupancy sensing in the thermostat, or a phone's location. Using a phone's location this way is sometimes called geofencing: the thermostat reacts when your phone leaves home or comes back.
For some households, these features remove a lot of repetitive adjusting. For others, they create friction: the house cools down while someone is sitting quietly in another room, or the temperature changes when no one asked it to.
What matters is control. Before buying, check whether that model's automatic features can be overridden by hand, adjusted, set to suggest changes rather than make them, or turned off completely. If the person living in the home wants the thermostat to do exactly what they set and nothing more, that should be easy to arrange.
When the internet or power goes out
If the internet goes down
Smart thermostats don't all behave the same way when the internet connection drops, so check your specific model rather than relying on general claims. A few things are generally true:
- Remote control from the app needs an internet connection. While the connection is down, no one can change the temperature from a phone.
- With many models, you can still adjust the temperature at the thermostat itself. This is one more reason the wall controls matter.
- Phone and email notifications generally need a working connection, so alerts may not reach anyone while it's down.
- Voice control typically depends on internet services, so it may stop working too.
Other behaviour varies between models. Look for clear answers to these questions in the manufacturer's documentation:
- Does the schedule keep running without the internet?
- Do automatic or home-and-away features keep working, or do they pause?
- Will anyone still receive alerts, and will you be told when the thermostat has gone offline?
- Does voice control still work?
If someone is counting on alerts, get these answers before you buy.
If the power goes out
An internet outage and a power outage are different problems. When only the internet is down, your furnace, heat pump or air conditioner may still have power and keep running as usual.
If your heating or cooling equipment doesn't have the electrical power it needs, no thermostat setting can make it run. That holds whether the whole house has lost power or only the equipment has. Some smart thermostats have a small internal battery, but it keeps the thermostat going, not your heating or cooling. If your internet router loses power, remote access and notifications stop too. It's also worth asking what happens to the thermostat's settings and schedule after a power interruption, because this differs between models.
Sharing control with family, and who gets the alerts
Giving someone else access
Remote access can be a real help. A partner can adjust the temperature on the way home, or a relative can help sort out a setting without making a trip.
Many smart thermostat systems let several household members have access, and many give each person their own sign-in. Not all do: some systems allow only one login, which everyone has to share. If more than one person will need access, check how sharing works before you buy. Where the app has a proper sharing or member feature, use it rather than giving out your password. That makes it easier to remove someone's access later.
For a broader look at how adding family members to smart-home apps generally works, see our Smart Home Guide for Older Adults.
Agreeing who changes what
This is Home Ease Guide's practical advice, not a rule from any official body. If another adult will be able to change the thermostat remotely, agree in advance who may change settings, when, and how the person living there will know. The resident's comfort and preferences come first. Remote access works best as help that's been asked for, not as control from a distance.
Know how your system handles this. In some apps, every invited member has the same permissions, and the main account holder can't see who made a change. Some thermostats offer a screen lock or a limit on the temperatures that can be set. Whether to use those is a decision for the household to make together.
Who will actually receive the alerts
Depending on the model, notifications may cover unusually high or low indoor temperatures, possible heating or cooling problems, and reminders such as changing the filter. Having access to a thermostat doesn't necessarily mean receiving its alerts. Who gets them can depend on:
- the app and how it handles notifications
- each person's role or permissions on the account
- whether alerts go by email, by phone notification or both, and to which addresses
- each person's own phone notification settings
So ask the practical question: who will actually receive the notifications you care about? If it matters, test it after setup rather than assuming everyone with access will be told.
What thermostat alerts can and can't do
A thermostat notification can let someone know something may be wrong. It isn't professional monitoring, emergency response or medical monitoring, and it doesn't replace smoke or carbon monoxide alarms. An alert also doesn't ensure anyone sees it or acts on it: phones get silenced, connections drop, and messages get missed.
If alerts are part of your household's plan, agree on who will respond and how. For the alarms that do protect against fire and carbon monoxide, see our guide to smoke and carbon monoxide alarms.
Will it work with your heating and cooling system?
This is the most important check of all, and it needs to happen before you buy. Most smart thermostats are designed for the common low-voltage wiring used by many furnaces, central air conditioners and heat pumps. Some systems need a different kind of thermostat, extra equipment, or a professional to set things up.
Systems that need a closer look
You don't need to understand how these systems work, only that compatibility deserves extra care if your home has one:
- Electric baseboard heat and other "line-voltage" systems. These run on standard household voltage rather than the low-voltage wiring most furnaces and central air systems use. Typical smart thermostats generally aren't compatible with them.
- Heat pumps, especially those with auxiliary or emergency heat (a backup electric heater).
- Dual-fuel systems, where a heat pump works alongside a gas or oil furnace.
- Boilers and radiant heating.
- Multi-stage and multi-zone systems, which have more than one level of heating or cooling, or separate thermostats for different parts of the house.
- Proprietary or "communicating" systems, whose equipment uses its own control signals rather than standard thermostat wiring.
- Very low-power ("millivolt") systems.
The best way to find out is the thermostat manufacturer's own compatibility checker, usually on its website. These tools generally ask what kind of heating and cooling you have, and which connection points on your current thermostat have wires attached, going by the printed labels rather than wire colour. If you'd rather not look behind your thermostat, a heating and cooling professional can answer those questions.
The C-wire, in plain terms
You'll often see the term C-wire, short for "common wire": a wire that can give a thermostat steady, continuous low-voltage power. Many smart thermostats need more power than a basic thermostat because of their screen and Wi-Fi.
- Some smart thermostats require a C-wire.
- Some can usually run without one.
- Some offer a power adapter or accessory as an alternative, but these work only with certain systems.
Because the requirements depend on both the thermostat and your system, let the compatibility checker or a professional tell you what's needed. This guide doesn't cover wiring. That work starts with the power to the heating and cooling system switched off, and is best left to someone confident doing it.
When professional installation makes sense
Many smart thermostat installations are straightforward. Manufacturers do recommend professional help in some situations, and it's worth arranging if:
- you're unsure about your wiring
- your system is line voltage, such as electric baseboard heat
- you have a dual-fuel system or a more complex heat pump setup
- your system uses proprietary or communicating controls
- the thermostat needs a power source your system doesn't seem to have
- you can't complete the compatibility check, or it can't confirm your system will work
A professional can confirm compatibility, sort out the power supply and set the thermostat up correctly for your equipment.
Energy savings: what the evidence supports
Energy savings depend mainly on how the thermostat is used, especially on "setbacks": turning the heat down, or the cooling up, for a stretch of hours while you're asleep or away.
The U.S. Department of Energy's 2022 Energy Saver Guide says you can save as much as 10% a year on heating and cooling by turning your thermostat down 7–10°F for 8 hours a day in the fall and winter, and up in the spring and summer. That figure is about the setback itself, not about any particular type of thermostat. Buying a smart thermostat doesn't by itself save 10%.
The same guide adds a caution for heat pumps. Don't set one back by hand if doing so brings on its backup electric heat. Instead, use a smart or programmable thermostat designed for heat pumps.
If saving energy is part of your reason for buying, look for the ENERGY STAR label. Smart thermostats that earn it have been certified as delivering energy savings, based on real-world data from homes using them. Not every smart thermostat carries the label. Whatever you choose, actual savings depend on your climate, your home, your equipment and your habits.
Rebates and utility programs
Some utilities and energy programs offer rebates on ENERGY STAR-certified smart thermostats. What's available changes over time and varies by area, so check with your electric or gas utility, or use ENERGY STAR's online rebate finder, before you buy.
Some utilities also run optional programs that can make small, temporary adjustments to enrolled thermostats when demand on the electricity grid is high. Terms and opt-out options vary by program, so read them before enrolling. ENERGY STAR-certified smart thermostats are required to let you override these requests.
Privacy and account security
A smart thermostat collects some information to do its job. Before switching on every feature, check:
- What it senses. Indoor temperature, and often humidity. Some models also sense motion or whether someone is home.
- Location. Home-and-away features may use your phone's location, if you turn them on.
- History. The app may keep a record of temperatures and of when your heating and cooling ran.
- Sharing. If you join a utility program, some thermostat data may be shared with that program.
- Access. Everyone with access to the account can usually see the thermostat's status and make changes.
The app's settings and the company's privacy information usually cover these. Turn on only the features you'll use.
For account security, the basics recommended by U.S. cybersecurity and consumer-protection agencies apply:
- Use a strong, unique password for the thermostat account.
- Turn on two-step verification (sometimes called two-factor or multifactor authentication) if your account offers it.
- Keep the app and the thermostat's software up to date.
- Review who has access from time to time, and remove anyone who no longer needs it.
What to check before buying
Use this table as your checklist. Not every row will matter to every household, so focus on the ones that matter to yours.
| What to check | Why it matters | How to find out |
|---|---|---|
| Changing the temperature at the thermostat | Probably the thing you'll do most often | Manual or manufacturer instructions; see it in person if you can |
| Editing the schedule at the wall, or only in the app | Some models allow schedule changes only in the app | Manual or manufacturer instructions |
| Compatibility with your heating and cooling system | A thermostat that doesn't match your system can't run it properly | The manufacturer's compatibility checker, or a heating and cooling professional |
| C-wire or other power requirement | Can decide whether a thermostat will work in your home | Compatibility checker; product specifications; a professional |
| Whether professional installation is advised | Some systems need expert setup | Compatibility checker results; the manufacturer's installation guidance |
| What keeps working without the internet | Schedules, automatic features, alerts and voice may behave differently | Manufacturer support pages or customer support |
| What happens to settings after a power interruption | This differs between models | Manufacturer support pages or customer support |
| Overriding or turning off automatic features | Keeps the resident in control | Manual, or the app's settings description |
| Sign-ins for other household members | Some systems use one shared login | Manufacturer support pages on sharing access |
| Who receives alerts | Access doesn't always mean receiving alerts | Manufacturer support pages; test after setup |
| Voice assistant compatibility | Works only with supported assistants | Product specifications; your assistant's app |
| Two-step verification | Adds protection to the account | The account's security settings or support pages |
| Utility program terms, if you're offered one | Programs may adjust your thermostat during peak demand | Your utility's program terms |
Frequently asked questions
Do smart thermostats work without Wi-Fi?
Partly, and it depends on the model. With many smart thermostats, you can still change the temperature at the thermostat itself when the internet is down. Remote control from the app needs a connection, phone and email alerts generally do too, and voice control typically depends on internet services. Whether schedules and automatic features keep running varies, so check the manufacturer's documentation for the model you're considering.
Do I need a C-wire for a smart thermostat?
Not always. A C-wire gives a thermostat steady power. Some smart thermostats require one, some can usually run without one, and some offer a power adapter that works only with certain systems. The manufacturer's compatibility checker, or a heating and cooling professional, can tell you what your system needs.
Will a smart thermostat lower my energy bills?
It can help, but savings depend mainly on how you use it. The U.S. Department of Energy's 2022 Energy Saver Guide says you can save as much as 10% a year on heating and cooling by turning your thermostat down 7–10°F for 8 hours a day in the fall and winter, and up in the spring and summer. That comes from the setback, not from buying a particular thermostat, and heat pumps need extra care. Actual results depend on your climate, home, equipment and habits.
Can a family member adjust my thermostat from somewhere else?
With a smart thermostat and a working internet connection, usually yes. Many systems let several people have access, often with their own sign-ins, though some use a single shared login. Agree in advance who may change settings and when. The person living in the home should stay in charge of their own comfort.
Is a smart thermostat hard to install?
On many common systems, installation is manageable. Start with the compatibility check, which shows whether your system and wiring suit the thermostat. Some situations call for a professional: line-voltage heat, complex heat pump setups, proprietary systems, or uncertainty about wiring or power.
Continue reading